Keep metadata during canonicalisation by jviotti · Pull Request #2341 · sourcemeta/core

jviotti · 2026-04-09T18:57:32Z

Signed-off-by: Juan Cruz Viotti jv@jviotti.com

Signed-off-by: Juan Cruz Viotti <jv@jviotti.com>

augmentcode · 2026-04-09T19:00:43Z

🤖 Augment PR Summary

Summary: This PR changes the alterschema canonicaliser to preserve schema metadata instead of stripping it during canonicalisation.

Changes:

Removed the NoMetadata canonicaliser rule and its build/registration wiring.
Stopped deleting annotation, comment, and unknown keywords as part of canonicalisation.
Adjusted 2020-12 canonicalisation expectations to retain metadata (e.g., title, contentEncoding, contentMediaType, contentSchema).
Deleted the test cases that previously asserted metadata was removed.

Technical Notes: Canonicalised output will now include non-validation keywords, which may affect consumers that relied on metadata-free canonical schemas.

_{🤖 Was this summary useful? React with 👍 or 👎}

augmentcode

Review completed. 1 suggestion posted.

Comment augment review to trigger a new review at any time.

augmentcode · 2026-04-09T19:00:44Z

test/alterschema/alterschema_canonicalize_2020_12_test.cc


  const sourcemeta::core::JSON expected = sourcemeta::core::parse_json(R"JSON({
    "$schema": "https://json-schema.org/draft/2020-12/schema",
+    "title": "My schema",


Now that canonicalisation preserves metadata (via removal of NoMetadata), consider reintroducing a few of the removed no_metadata_* cases as positive tests that $comment, description, and unknown keywords are retained (including nested subschemas) to keep this behavior covered.

Severity: medium

_{🤖 Was this useful? React with 👍 or 👎, or 🚀 if it prevented an incident/outage.}

github-actions

Benchmark (macos/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: `f202c7b`	Previous: `53a1888`	Ratio
`Regex_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk`	`1.6183674776937913` ns/iter	`1.761148578662857` ns/iter	`0.92`
`Regex_Caret_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk_Dollar`	`1.6200354384250042` ns/iter	`1.8417340342895299` ns/iter	`0.88`
`Regex_Period_Asterisk`	`1.597316446113467` ns/iter	`1.6941186416023961` ns/iter	`0.94`
`Regex_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group`	`1.6195897010628129` ns/iter	`1.6847244214158463` ns/iter	`0.96`
`Regex_Period_Plus`	`1.8823959289949392` ns/iter	`2.1002026924615644` ns/iter	`0.90`
`Regex_Period`	`1.8858779336579388` ns/iter	`2.0792338062017377` ns/iter	`0.91`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Plus_Dollar`	`1.9220031454375641` ns/iter	`2.077082144864504` ns/iter	`0.93`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Plus_Group_Dollar`	`1.9105482824256275` ns/iter	`2.1059663535667856` ns/iter	`0.91`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Asterisk_Dollar`	`1.6427994186032777` ns/iter	`1.732134694716024` ns/iter	`0.95`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group_Dollar`	`1.6528502058669847` ns/iter	`1.8849108028396115` ns/iter	`0.88`
`Regex_Caret_X_Hyphen`	`6.292148064118869` ns/iter	`6.648850056669222` ns/iter	`0.95`
`Regex_Period_Md_Dollar`	`18.77642750538908` ns/iter	`20.662196998015194` ns/iter	`0.91`
`Regex_Caret_Slash_Period_Asterisk`	`4.537844563568317` ns/iter	`4.834273330307589` ns/iter	`0.94`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Range_Dollar`	`1.7006849485464235` ns/iter	`1.809960133986429` ns/iter	`0.94`
`Regex_Nested_Backtrack`	`24.859488404489536` ns/iter	`25.732299573927044` ns/iter	`0.97`
`JSON_Array_Of_Objects_Unique`	`346.6668249788072` ns/iter	`375.78585860411636` ns/iter	`0.92`
`JSON_Parse_1`	`4036.908979434099` ns/iter	`4215.869315104811` ns/iter	`0.96`
`JSON_Parse_Real`	`6808.869102473111` ns/iter	`6615.029130505907` ns/iter	`1.03`
`JSON_Parse_Decimal`	`8680.276825495193` ns/iter	`8331.757087912336` ns/iter	`1.04`
`JSON_Parse_Schema_ISO_Language`	`4187014.2045455207` ns/iter	`4176153.037036907` ns/iter	`1.00`
`JSON_Fast_Hash_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`64.1871653293543` ns/iter	`64.78592930969943` ns/iter	`0.99`
`JSON_Equality_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`167.6503249544164` ns/iter	`160.18548793806562` ns/iter	`1.05`
`JSON_Divisible_By_Decimal`	`194.7263865922628` ns/iter	`183.01342274021587` ns/iter	`1.06`
`JSON_String_Equal/10`	`7.703300012933285` ns/iter	`6.924435467850643` ns/iter	`1.11`
`JSON_String_Equal/100`	`7.026778161104307` ns/iter	`6.56102592687938` ns/iter	`1.07`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Perfect_Hash/10`	`0.8165264776618517` ns/iter	`0.7649560260886762` ns/iter	`1.07`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Runtime_Perfect_Hash/10`	`3.7054080373621177` ns/iter	`3.3396739025554805` ns/iter	`1.11`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/10`	`2.8016528021170317` ns/iter	`2.392688979873828` ns/iter	`1.17`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/100`	`2.426453587488856` ns/iter	`2.0674242402945713` ns/iter	`1.17`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/10`	`1.5670147794687765` ns/iter	`1.4350235707677668` ns/iter	`1.09`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/100`	`2.5104657075718064` ns/iter	`2.190509952297973` ns/iter	`1.15`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Same_Length`	`2.6236007927504383` ns/iter	`2.355120683368236` ns/iter	`1.11`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Small`	`2.5947814580092965` ns/iter	`2.3821419570407736` ns/iter	`1.09`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Large`	`3.121073649873406` ns/iter	`2.4206270527667644` ns/iter	`1.29`
`Pointer_Object_Traverse`	`19.60369941077847` ns/iter	`16.997500254377307` ns/iter	`1.15`
`Pointer_Object_Try_Traverse`	`23.675084894929252` ns/iter	`21.37694632443445` ns/iter	`1.11`
`Pointer_Push_Back_Pointer_To_Weak_Pointer`	`163.93418656273016` ns/iter	`161.94266333560407` ns/iter	`1.01`
`Pointer_Walker_Schema_ISO_Language`	`5004070.560000097` ns/iter	`4463576.257861396` ns/iter	`1.12`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/0`	`1267315.3114185291` ns/iter	`1235953.5606836476` ns/iter	`1.03`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/1`	`1546074.71940912` ns/iter	`1586132.8585462654` ns/iter	`0.97`
`Pointer_Position_Tracker_Get_Deeply_Nested`	`451.19727157759803` ns/iter	`386.22753498682175` ns/iter	`1.17`
`Schema_Frame_WoT_References`	`5300170.235714827` ns/iter	`5045776.268115583` ns/iter	`1.05`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_References`	`30667474.34615116` ns/iter	`26094757.740742758` ns/iter	`1.18`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations`	`23685565.958336007` ns/iter	`24826614.607146017` ns/iter	`0.95`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations`	`81185439.77778043` ns/iter	`75831505.12499514` ns/iter	`1.07`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References`	`51470253.41667207` ns/iter	`45018611.99999979` ns/iter	`1.14`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable`	`391297812.5000563` ns/iter	`438754666.5000173` ns/iter	`0.89`
`Schema_Iterator_ISO_Language`	`1919767.4501426192` ns/iter	`2077575.3949579075` ns/iter	`0.92`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON`	`82645203.12499712` ns/iter	`72805713.00000499` ns/iter	`1.14`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language`	`9888155.632351674` ns/iter	`9287175.217949448` ns/iter	`1.06`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`14727833.333329462` ns/iter	`14937507.653060641` ns/iter	`0.99`
`Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`79923800.77775529` ns/iter	`78515346.99998158` ns/iter	`1.02`
`Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12`	`1419847.5573799915` ns/iter	`1395410.5236433465` ns/iter	`1.02`
`Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References`	`311046062.5000542` ns/iter	`265118763.99998376` ns/iter	`1.17`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3`	`145741483.39997917` ns/iter	`147904400.0000158` ns/iter	`0.99`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC`	`41241029.150000945` ns/iter	`31701736.727272462` ns/iter	`1.30`
`Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD`	`650053999.9999546` ns/iter	`427757915.99996185` ns/iter	`1.52`
`Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs`	`75661546.33332188` ns/iter	`64917522.7272694` ns/iter	`1.17`
`EditorSchema_ForEditor_EmbeddedResources`	`10829903.70689615` ns/iter	`10871521.716412917` ns/iter	`1.00`
`URITemplateRouter_Create`	`16940.99912853161` ns/iter	`15817.333240105887` ns/iter	`1.07`
`URITemplateRouter_Match`	`166.5696227989787` ns/iter	`165.26991979503572` ns/iter	`1.01`
`URITemplateRouter_Match_BasePath`	`200.07278730160397` ns/iter	`193.98140983102115` ns/iter	`1.03`
`URITemplateRouterView_Restore`	`13713.115335508099` ns/iter	`14697.175892766281` ns/iter	`0.93`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match`	`139.43070641920522` ns/iter	`129.45464802127003` ns/iter	`1.08`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match_BasePath`	`139.21232735707406` ns/iter	`147.39650257764947` ns/iter	`0.94`
`URITemplateRouterView_Arguments`	`381.8032819237021` ns/iter	`450.6885397651375` ns/iter	`0.85`
`HTML_Build_Table_100000`	`60373961.74999306` ns/iter	`69388295.90000068` ns/iter	`0.87`
`HTML_Render_Table_100000`	`5013976.214591673` ns/iter	`2787576.923076766` ns/iter	`1.80`

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

github-actions

Benchmark (linux/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: `f202c7b`	Previous: `53a1888`	Ratio
`Regex_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk`	`3.111702435953019` ns/iter	`2.0663224042160806` ns/iter	`1.51`
`Regex_Caret_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk_Dollar`	`3.1104362915794805` ns/iter	`2.0177906513742268` ns/iter	`1.54`
`Regex_Period_Asterisk`	`3.110113659128499` ns/iter	`2.0180390244114825` ns/iter	`1.54`
`Regex_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group`	`3.109674377779112` ns/iter	`2.01730489867409` ns/iter	`1.54`
`Regex_Period_Plus`	`3.1102523120767` ns/iter	`2.3162112602144913` ns/iter	`1.34`
`Regex_Period`	`3.2189611754426886` ns/iter	`2.305269562770997` ns/iter	`1.40`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Plus_Dollar`	`2.883345194272057` ns/iter	`2.308896859254345` ns/iter	`1.25`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Plus_Group_Dollar`	`3.2097058384910895` ns/iter	`2.307828545891703` ns/iter	`1.39`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Asterisk_Dollar`	`3.85175760888665` ns/iter	`2.04900597103575` ns/iter	`1.88`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group_Dollar`	`3.7344393322541256` ns/iter	`2.026194674787379` ns/iter	`1.84`
`Regex_Caret_X_Hyphen`	`10.270983279131869` ns/iter	`8.658638574659966` ns/iter	`1.19`
`Regex_Period_Md_Dollar`	`27.66674201433312` ns/iter	`25.224121178038896` ns/iter	`1.10`
`Regex_Caret_Slash_Period_Asterisk`	`6.535439817983971` ns/iter	`9.049528066422269` ns/iter	`0.72`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Range_Dollar`	`4.049119799269038` ns/iter	`2.324815488463343` ns/iter	`1.74`
`Regex_Nested_Backtrack`	`49.17371661821332` ns/iter	`44.24337038596032` ns/iter	`1.11`
`JSON_Array_Of_Objects_Unique`	`387.40549882612726` ns/iter	`345.40730005080354` ns/iter	`1.12`
`JSON_Parse_1`	`5834.996114622127` ns/iter	`5092.407920705965` ns/iter	`1.15`
`JSON_Parse_Real`	`10805.593009278551` ns/iter	`10257.238664636441` ns/iter	`1.05`
`JSON_Parse_Decimal`	`11881.786382636168` ns/iter	`9943.905513486907` ns/iter	`1.19`
`JSON_Parse_Schema_ISO_Language`	`3578438.287179499` ns/iter	`3208437.6342593427` ns/iter	`1.12`
`JSON_Fast_Hash_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`53.532973199113044` ns/iter	`48.957973048363385` ns/iter	`1.09`
`JSON_Equality_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`160.95649205129402` ns/iter	`139.93654766075986` ns/iter	`1.15`
`JSON_Divisible_By_Decimal`	`245.95206820814292` ns/iter	`255.7593548232735` ns/iter	`0.96`
`JSON_String_Equal/10`	`6.232172001832078` ns/iter	`4.609148286224667` ns/iter	`1.35`
`JSON_String_Equal/100`	`6.85034141272656` ns/iter	`5.76447477529441` ns/iter	`1.19`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Perfect_Hash/10`	`0.9357323849075947` ns/iter	`0.6916128512724797` ns/iter	`1.35`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Runtime_Perfect_Hash/10`	`10.268510239098259` ns/iter	`9.508413247719501` ns/iter	`1.08`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/10`	`2.4894395512842946` ns/iter	`2.0179439274583664` ns/iter	`1.23`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/100`	`2.4959976087070954` ns/iter	`2.023991953876743` ns/iter	`1.23`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/10`	`2.1793780773914673` ns/iter	`1.7291699756436842` ns/iter	`1.26`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/100`	`6.539972514148793` ns/iter	`6.62405769343461` ns/iter	`0.99`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Same_Length`	`3.737861583118668` ns/iter	`3.408741061551359` ns/iter	`1.10`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Small`	`3.738236822397352` ns/iter	`3.556439613644174` ns/iter	`1.05`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Large`	`3.7379149411602044` ns/iter	`3.410799137531841` ns/iter	`1.10`
`Pointer_Object_Traverse`	`25.409262602543013` ns/iter	`24.321926968753782` ns/iter	`1.04`
`Pointer_Object_Try_Traverse`	`27.943467474314204` ns/iter	`28.3415398487861` ns/iter	`0.99`
`Pointer_Push_Back_Pointer_To_Weak_Pointer`	`155.68347138302406` ns/iter	`176.31022498891699` ns/iter	`0.88`
`Pointer_Walker_Schema_ISO_Language`	`3050702.343347724` ns/iter	`3051477.951754677` ns/iter	`1.00`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/0`	`1449997.3409091248` ns/iter	`1125650.2728733423` ns/iter	`1.29`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/1`	`1758364.8936708781` ns/iter	`2055214.6647227446` ns/iter	`0.86`
`Pointer_Position_Tracker_Get_Deeply_Nested`	`652.2870929395023` ns/iter	`719.483922726216` ns/iter	`0.91`
`Schema_Frame_WoT_References`	`5073552.642336198` ns/iter	`4583357.546052687` ns/iter	`1.11`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_References`	`20739277.647060268` ns/iter	`19788361.628574032` ns/iter	`1.05`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations`	`19071794.837837055` ns/iter	`17986233.564101893` ns/iter	`1.06`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations`	`93886460.71428347` ns/iter	`92282126.00000265` ns/iter	`1.02`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References`	`37432877.73683709` ns/iter	`37873197.55555371` ns/iter	`0.99`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable`	`549602979.0000421` ns/iter	`764119901.9999477` ns/iter	`0.72`
`Schema_Iterator_ISO_Language`	`2267125.8488748693` ns/iter	`2141213.5957446736` ns/iter	`1.06`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON`	`114027465.39999953` ns/iter	`113671065.60001048` ns/iter	`1.00`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language`	`4706986.610738372` ns/iter	`4707517.527396878` ns/iter	`1.00`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`18840223.32432311` ns/iter	`19612355.28571511` ns/iter	`0.96`
`Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`99807124.00001343` ns/iter	`99549377.4285673` ns/iter	`1.00`
`Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12`	`1668936.0849469616` ns/iter	`1533682.8967020256` ns/iter	`1.09`
`Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References`	`366883852.4999955` ns/iter	`368937340.49999696` ns/iter	`0.99`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3`	`207298347.3333352` ns/iter	`187885157.75000292` ns/iter	`1.10`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC`	`32917567.61904621` ns/iter	`31222402.81818346` ns/iter	`1.05`
`Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD`	`574819117.9999367` ns/iter	`536716995.00000614` ns/iter	`1.07`
`Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs`	`118427763.66667825` ns/iter	`94436614.12500149` ns/iter	`1.25`
`EditorSchema_ForEditor_EmbeddedResources`	`13911523.739996027` ns/iter	`12478882.732141627` ns/iter	`1.11`
`URITemplateRouter_Create`	`16578.945378349064` ns/iter	`12529.379914944982` ns/iter	`1.32`
`URITemplateRouter_Match`	`173.58401590789612` ns/iter	`138.4861691776845` ns/iter	`1.25`
`URITemplateRouter_Match_BasePath`	`204.39096487144766` ns/iter	`156.89234059651588` ns/iter	`1.30`
`URITemplateRouterView_Restore`	`5079.350905916115` ns/iter	`2480.9278932247253` ns/iter	`2.05`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match`	`142.72019314099046` ns/iter	`142.91272468951325` ns/iter	`1.00`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match_BasePath`	`164.31183407237938` ns/iter	`158.02740846515752` ns/iter	`1.04`
`URITemplateRouterView_Arguments`	`433.81213162777954` ns/iter	`426.7303388716929` ns/iter	`1.02`
`HTML_Build_Table_100000`	`63408506.81817756` ns/iter	`70908386.3999922` ns/iter	`0.89`
`HTML_Render_Table_100000`	`5668017.341666124` ns/iter	`9670044.945205392` ns/iter	`0.59`

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

github-actions

Benchmark (windows/msvc)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: `f202c7b`	Previous: `53a1888`	Ratio
`Regex_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk`	`4.121503906250165` ns/iter	`2.913862900485264` ns/iter	`1.41`
`Regex_Caret_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk_Dollar`	`4.091520185876495` ns/iter	`3.03835700486036` ns/iter	`1.35`
`Regex_Period_Asterisk`	`4.406176874999801` ns/iter	`3.2416883928557843` ns/iter	`1.36`
`Regex_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group`	`4.10473225263253` ns/iter	`2.7932138826808246` ns/iter	`1.47`
`Regex_Period_Plus`	`4.710151785715766` ns/iter	`3.21813750502909` ns/iter	`1.46`
`Regex_Period`	`4.764871215993401` ns/iter	`3.2098955357144274` ns/iter	`1.48`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Plus_Dollar`	`4.429534999999873` ns/iter	`2.921649505015859` ns/iter	`1.52`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Plus_Group_Dollar`	`4.425518749999924` ns/iter	`2.935299393388518` ns/iter	`1.51`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Asterisk_Dollar`	`4.111680051985742` ns/iter	`2.8358738826615077` ns/iter	`1.45`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group_Dollar`	`4.1034784448275685` ns/iter	`3.0275189468383186` ns/iter	`1.36`
`Regex_Caret_X_Hyphen`	`7.286257812500553` ns/iter	`5.954987499998358` ns/iter	`1.22`
`Regex_Period_Md_Dollar`	`35.00660556915033` ns/iter	`31.200227678575793` ns/iter	`1.12`
`Regex_Caret_Slash_Period_Asterisk`	`6.927991071427592` ns/iter	`5.596941964284951` ns/iter	`1.24`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Range_Dollar`	`4.087681919643212` ns/iter	`3.7072114219498125` ns/iter	`1.10`
`Regex_Nested_Backtrack`	`97.19382155385709` ns/iter	`91.74054501161794` ns/iter	`1.06`
`JSON_Array_Of_Objects_Unique`	`465.3380726201402` ns/iter	`392.3418526787157` ns/iter	`1.19`
`JSON_Parse_1`	`8051.199776785621` ns/iter	`8397.894652258714` ns/iter	`0.96`
`JSON_Parse_Real`	`15934.352678575537` ns/iter	`18213.31712805134` ns/iter	`0.87`
`JSON_Parse_Decimal`	`15897.415178568304` ns/iter	`17091.97637510578` ns/iter	`0.93`
`JSON_Parse_Schema_ISO_Language`	`5920391.071427389` ns/iter	`27136827.678568967` ns/iter	`0.22`
`JSON_Fast_Hash_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`58.16437499999795` ns/iter	`1129.8540000000655` ns/iter	`0.051479549570116655`
`JSON_Equality_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`264.3195787643273` ns/iter	`673.2225000000653` ns/iter	`0.39`
`JSON_Divisible_By_Decimal`	`249.34364285716777` ns/iter	`317.41024155966375` ns/iter	`0.79`
`JSON_String_Equal/10`	`12.290207142858176` ns/iter	`15.427826785712893` ns/iter	`0.80`
`JSON_String_Equal/100`	`12.933985714283835` ns/iter	`17.722308035713144` ns/iter	`0.73`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Perfect_Hash/10`	`1.8902616981162335` ns/iter	`1.6200865625009442` ns/iter	`1.17`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Runtime_Perfect_Hash/10`	`12.911397933430809` ns/iter	`12.071083928576952` ns/iter	`1.07`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/10`	`3.137892830618603` ns/iter	`2.9870117464050967` ns/iter	`1.05`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/100`	`3.1566621163081936` ns/iter	`2.0863777436732462` ns/iter	`1.51`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/10`	`4.102962053572158` ns/iter	`2.953822900468488` ns/iter	`1.39`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/100`	`14.388454623263929` ns/iter	`14.84850127299617` ns/iter	`0.97`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Same_Length`	`5.054478571427775` ns/iter	`4.747325469807756` ns/iter	`1.06`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Small`	`3.7773733861111167` ns/iter	`3.895861607143201` ns/iter	`0.97`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Large`	`3.773865528975097` ns/iter	`3.5524897704425826` ns/iter	`1.06`
`Pointer_Object_Traverse`	`44.13418686277165` ns/iter	`38.91257609084392` ns/iter	`1.13`
`Pointer_Object_Try_Traverse`	`53.05775892856397` ns/iter	`50.23833999998715` ns/iter	`1.06`
`Pointer_Push_Back_Pointer_To_Weak_Pointer`	`160.16359374998297` ns/iter	`183.72326453503052` ns/iter	`0.87`
`Pointer_Walker_Schema_ISO_Language`	`11520017.187500287` ns/iter	`13102779.999999257` ns/iter	`0.88`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/0`	`1994959.531773102` ns/iter	`2226272.3484852193` ns/iter	`0.90`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/1`	`3111491.9491521074` ns/iter	`4020508.9385482767` ns/iter	`0.77`
`Pointer_Position_Tracker_Get_Deeply_Nested`	`639.4801339284178` ns/iter	`531.9363794681339` ns/iter	`1.20`
`Schema_Frame_WoT_References`	`10198137.333333459` ns/iter	`9862054.687502563` ns/iter	`1.03`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_References`	`44671920.00000371` ns/iter	`44916981.81817066` ns/iter	`0.99`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations`	`41988494.11763791` ns/iter	`41922500.000001654` ns/iter	`1.00`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations`	`199718700.00002432` ns/iter	`195827733.33331716` ns/iter	`1.02`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References`	`96545028.57142688` ns/iter	`93970857.14285173` ns/iter	`1.03`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable`	`523061900.00012976` ns/iter	`625525500.0000943` ns/iter	`0.84`
`Schema_Iterator_ISO_Language`	`5190809.000000627` ns/iter	`5975973.999998132` ns/iter	`0.87`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON`	`290299399.9999808` ns/iter	`307077350.0000996` ns/iter	`0.95`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language`	`16446624.444445966` ns/iter	`18259448.780487973` ns/iter	`0.90`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`49595493.333329916` ns/iter	`52253240.00002729` ns/iter	`0.95`
`Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`202258966.6667045` ns/iter	`196133766.66666225` ns/iter	`1.03`
`Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12`	`2895158.634542661` ns/iter	`2837134.939754212` ns/iter	`1.02`
`Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References`	`1491322200.0000134` ns/iter	`1435492100.000374` ns/iter	`1.04`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3`	`322364949.999951` ns/iter	`319697499.9998474` ns/iter	`1.01`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC`	`64031745.45454765` ns/iter	`61751536.363648154` ns/iter	`1.04`
`Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD`	`1042799000.0000591` ns/iter	`926138799.9999897` ns/iter	`1.13`
`Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs`	`152070474.99995953` ns/iter	`128407383.33337261` ns/iter	`1.18`
`EditorSchema_ForEditor_EmbeddedResources`	`27914024.0000288` ns/iter	`27610016.666623473` ns/iter	`1.01`
`URITemplateRouter_Create`	`22975.364114236578` ns/iter	`21640.765625008386` ns/iter	`1.06`
`URITemplateRouter_Match`	`212.7966713037499` ns/iter	`231.0659375000057` ns/iter	`0.92`
`URITemplateRouter_Match_BasePath`	`245.89449999999553` ns/iter	`260.92864780936435` ns/iter	`0.94`
`URITemplateRouterView_Restore`	`31399.53125000261` ns/iter	`24812.674078857883` ns/iter	`1.27`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match`	`153.63455357143405` ns/iter	`162.53947042229098` ns/iter	`0.95`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match_BasePath`	`176.5182640525995` ns/iter	`189.24489189677803` ns/iter	`0.93`
`URITemplateRouterView_Arguments`	`444.49744567025976` ns/iter	`437.8867500000183` ns/iter	`1.02`
`HTML_Build_Table_100000`	`84943644.44444121` ns/iter	`105500128.57148822` ns/iter	`0.81`
`HTML_Render_Table_100000`	`7732795.555557459` ns/iter	`12374860.714284556` ns/iter	`0.62`

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

github-actions

Benchmark (linux/gcc)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: `f202c7b`	Previous: `53a1888`	Ratio
`HTML_Build_Table_100000`	`72795809.3333301` ns/iter	`68376563.50000998` ns/iter	`1.06`
`HTML_Render_Table_100000`	`4933956.863310119` ns/iter	`9911984.285716763` ns/iter	`0.50`
`URITemplateRouter_Create`	`14516.420380060641` ns/iter	`11407.099233900046` ns/iter	`1.27`
`URITemplateRouter_Match`	`171.71547851639068` ns/iter	`160.7309541879331` ns/iter	`1.07`
`URITemplateRouter_Match_BasePath`	`203.79606306422218` ns/iter	`178.53060765177165` ns/iter	`1.14`
`URITemplateRouterView_Restore`	`6379.027062633458` ns/iter	`2472.5750705128517` ns/iter	`2.58`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match`	`132.10118464252233` ns/iter	`121.81222898581952` ns/iter	`1.08`
`URITemplateRouterView_Match_BasePath`	`152.4260804550432` ns/iter	`138.9221454570283` ns/iter	`1.10`
`URITemplateRouterView_Arguments`	`456.71487401552434` ns/iter	`497.18884597564465` ns/iter	`0.92`
`EditorSchema_ForEditor_EmbeddedResources`	`14483161.812497279` ns/iter	`12883762.72220746` ns/iter	`1.12`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3`	`200334541.66665855` ns/iter	`177949570.9999992` ns/iter	`1.13`
`Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC`	`37122178.000004165` ns/iter	`32647529.181810405` ns/iter	`1.14`
`Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD`	`597450985.0002505` ns/iter	`519256943.99983513` ns/iter	`1.15`
`Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs`	`115902258.50000024` ns/iter	`91870279.00000544` ns/iter	`1.26`
`Schema_Frame_WoT_References`	`5679830.887097816` ns/iter	`5000600.599998961` ns/iter	`1.14`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_References`	`23423506.86666729` ns/iter	`21386373.4545474` ns/iter	`1.10`
`Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations`	`22510496.624995824` ns/iter	`19434955.028568115` ns/iter	`1.16`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations`	`101986499.42857887` ns/iter	`92532064.12500958` ns/iter	`1.10`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References`	`42358717.52940939` ns/iter	`38353833.61110366` ns/iter	`1.10`
`Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable`	`596128877.9997176` ns/iter	`695245316.9999444` ns/iter	`0.86`
`Schema_Iterator_ISO_Language`	`2433996.9034481957` ns/iter	`2456492.226148563` ns/iter	`0.99`
`Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON`	`230535233.66669047` ns/iter	`198899139.49998572` ns/iter	`1.16`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language`	`4781538.283784689` ns/iter	`4620565.715232556` ns/iter	`1.03`
`Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`22120801.129029777` ns/iter	`23210157.48387459` ns/iter	`0.95`
`Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON`	`108780484.42860486` ns/iter	`98106685.28569165` ns/iter	`1.11`
`Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12`	`1822529.6901051754` ns/iter	`1725870.3022156716` ns/iter	`1.06`
`Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References`	`386511930.5000917` ns/iter	`358567087.5000915` ns/iter	`1.08`
`Pointer_Object_Traverse`	`27.05082642254415` ns/iter	`26.592319788163703` ns/iter	`1.02`
`Pointer_Object_Try_Traverse`	`26.796931562997184` ns/iter	`27.808393152600004` ns/iter	`0.96`
`Pointer_Push_Back_Pointer_To_Weak_Pointer`	`176.70088278213024` ns/iter	`157.3407921064606` ns/iter	`1.12`
`Pointer_Walker_Schema_ISO_Language`	`3689247.223958839` ns/iter	`3200807.1643831413` ns/iter	`1.15`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/0`	`1602474.412844362` ns/iter	`1389392.9049505224` ns/iter	`1.15`
`Pointer_Maybe_Tracked_Deeply_Nested/1`	`1810131.095855204` ns/iter	`1789708.7168828924` ns/iter	`1.01`
`Pointer_Position_Tracker_Get_Deeply_Nested`	`418.53320338118533` ns/iter	`405.9320093901155` ns/iter	`1.03`
`JSON_Array_Of_Objects_Unique`	`427.27937623588014` ns/iter	`366.4157464371208` ns/iter	`1.17`
`JSON_Parse_1`	`7894.999966318763` ns/iter	`6774.9104642377815` ns/iter	`1.17`
`JSON_Parse_Real`	`12255.42478818924` ns/iter	`10934.89689382797` ns/iter	`1.12`
`JSON_Parse_Decimal`	`17105.82673206687` ns/iter	`14498.176932615432` ns/iter	`1.18`
`JSON_Parse_Schema_ISO_Language`	`4628056.019867213` ns/iter	`4098115.274853743` ns/iter	`1.13`
`JSON_Fast_Hash_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`66.7222898490324` ns/iter	`48.754539340198406` ns/iter	`1.37`
`JSON_Equality_Helm_Chart_Lock`	`180.96619246377074` ns/iter	`141.01329976710215` ns/iter	`1.28`
`JSON_Divisible_By_Decimal`	`236.0046935283035` ns/iter	`254.27132861946149` ns/iter	`0.93`
`JSON_String_Equal/10`	`6.418228896414415` ns/iter	`5.297246633680895` ns/iter	`1.21`
`JSON_String_Equal/100`	`7.128710864924117` ns/iter	`6.454139908741178` ns/iter	`1.10`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Perfect_Hash/10`	`0.7093033125460155` ns/iter	`0.8262185384271377` ns/iter	`0.86`
`JSON_String_Equal_Small_By_Runtime_Perfect_Hash/10`	`23.16165037051875` ns/iter	`12.972027484870841` ns/iter	`1.79`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/10`	`1.760819858276117` ns/iter	`1.153663580513943` ns/iter	`1.53`
`JSON_String_Fast_Hash/100`	`1.7620249047300833` ns/iter	`1.153608449034268` ns/iter	`1.53`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/10`	`1.4074738630646697` ns/iter	`1.440790668535243` ns/iter	`0.98`
`JSON_String_Key_Hash/100`	`14.758563268576667` ns/iter	`11.827863532176742` ns/iter	`1.25`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Same_Length`	`3.5178812768260497` ns/iter	`3.7717052289334014` ns/iter	`0.93`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Small`	`3.871364728252662` ns/iter	`3.24234732805236` ns/iter	`1.19`
`JSON_Object_Defines_Miss_Too_Large`	`3.8748266776071705` ns/iter	`3.209053801376869` ns/iter	`1.21`
`Regex_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk`	`1.7598274019866447` ns/iter	`1.4410862881652817` ns/iter	`1.22`
`Regex_Caret_Lower_S_Or_Upper_S_Asterisk_Dollar`	`1.407915043009497` ns/iter	`1.4412451545682954` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Period_Asterisk`	`1.407118900749471` ns/iter	`1.4431919693105346` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group`	`1.4085728719242674` ns/iter	`1.44182261999947` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Period_Plus`	`1.4112331946231809` ns/iter	`1.4423559883861001` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Period`	`1.4079671847088333` ns/iter	`1.441368380017516` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Plus_Dollar`	`1.4085071674708989` ns/iter	`1.4408080907484466` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Plus_Group_Dollar`	`1.4077611804546486` ns/iter	`1.440747108814618` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Asterisk_Dollar`	`1.4074789186827426` ns/iter	`1.4415188621319739` ns/iter	`0.98`
`Regex_Caret_Group_Period_Asterisk_Group_Dollar`	`1.4069614104752517` ns/iter	`1.7292660318655704` ns/iter	`0.81`
`Regex_Caret_X_Hyphen`	`11.601702196641979` ns/iter	`8.356962984304095` ns/iter	`1.39`
`Regex_Period_Md_Dollar`	`34.04530676875662` ns/iter	`24.041442719161914` ns/iter	`1.42`
`Regex_Caret_Slash_Period_Asterisk`	`4.3280966065198685` ns/iter	`8.064246622445165` ns/iter	`0.54`
`Regex_Caret_Period_Range_Dollar`	`1.7585574636802517` ns/iter	`1.4409596436570766` ns/iter	`1.22`
`Regex_Nested_Backtrack`	`51.92174427049088` ns/iter	`41.75513992586903` ns/iter	`1.24`

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

Keep metadata during canonicalisation

f202c7b

Signed-off-by: Juan Cruz Viotti <jv@jviotti.com>

jviotti merged commit 95bc2b8 into main Apr 9, 2026
13 checks passed

jviotti deleted the keep-metadata branch April 9, 2026 18:58

augmentcode bot reviewed Apr 9, 2026

View reviewed changes

github-actions bot reviewed Apr 9, 2026

View reviewed changes

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Uh oh!

Keep metadata during canonicalisation#2341

Keep metadata during canonicalisation#2341
jviotti merged 1 commit intomainfrom
keep-metadata

jviotti commented Apr 9, 2026

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

augmentcode bot commented Apr 9, 2026

Uh oh!

augmentcode bot left a comment

Uh oh!

augmentcode bot Apr 9, 2026

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

1 participant

Uh oh!

Conversation

jviotti commented Apr 9, 2026

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

augmentcode bot commented Apr 9, 2026

Uh oh!

augmentcode bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

augmentcode bot Apr 9, 2026

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Benchmark (macos/llvm)

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Benchmark (linux/llvm)

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Benchmark (windows/msvc)

Uh oh!

github-actions bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Benchmark (linux/gcc)

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

1 participant